Joey Caudill

Bio

Height 6'5"
Weight 215 lbs
Hometown Mansfield, OH
High School Lexington
Rating ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Recruiting

⭐⭐⭐⭐ Class of 2026
#434 National
0.8928 Rating

Scouting Report

B+
89 / 100 Ceiling 89 • Floor 81
year 1 contributor NFL Rd 5

A high-upside athlete making the transition from high school quarterback to college tight end. Caudill possesses an ideal frame and a background that suggests a high football IQ, though he is raw from a technical standpoint at his projected position.

Physical Profile

Stands at an impressive 6-foot-5 and weighs in the 215-232 pound range, a prototypical frame for a modern tight end with room to add significant muscle mass. His background as a dual-threat quarterback indicates good functional athleticism and speed. The combination of height and length gives him a large catch radius.

Play Style

Currently a do-it-all offensive weapon at the high school level who excels with the ball in his hands. He plays with a physical, downhill mentality and shows natural athleticism in the open field. His leadership and competitive drive are evident on film, where he consistently fights for extra yardage and takes command of the offense.

Strengths

  • Versatility and Athleticism: Played quarterback, tight end, linebacker, and even defensive back in high school, showcasing a diverse skill set. In one playoff game, he amassed 385 all-purpose yards and seven touchdowns, demonstrating his dynamic playmaking ability.
  • Physicality and Toughness: His film as a quarterback shows a powerful, physical running style, which projects well to the tight end position for breaking tackles and gaining yards after the catch. Recruiting analysts note his toughness and no-nonsense, hard-working mentality.
  • High Football IQ: As a high school quarterback, he has a deep understanding of offensive schemes and defensive coverages, which should accelerate his development at tight end. This background often leads to strong leadership qualities.

Areas to Improve

  • Route Running Nuances: Lacks experience running a full route tree and will need to develop the finer points of creating separation against collegiate-level defenders.
  • Blocking Technique: Coming from a quarterback background, he will need significant development in both run blocking and pass protection, including fundamentals like hand placement, leverage, and footwork.

College Projection

Projects as a developmental 'F' or move tight end with significant long-term potential. Given his raw skill set at the position, a redshirt year to add mass and refine his technique is likely. His ceiling is a multi-year starter at the Power Four level with the potential to become a key offensive weapon due to his athletic gifts and football background.

Best Fit

A pro-style or spread offense that utilizes athletic tight ends who can create mismatches in the passing game. A program with a strong history of developing tight ends, like his committed school Michigan State, is an ideal environment to maximize his high ceiling by coaching his transition from quarterback.

Player Comparison

Jake Butt Michigan • Denver Broncos 78% match

Both share the ideal 6'5" frame with lean but athletic build that projects to multiple positions - likely tight end or wide receiver. Butt was similarly ranked as a solid 4-star prospect (#400s nationally) from the Midwest with strong fundamentals, suggesting both have the versatility and developmental upside that college coaches value in taller, athletic prospects who can grow into their frames.